The June 2006 edition of the Yale Law Journal is available here, and as Eric Muller notes, it boasts a Colloquium with “head-turningly nasty exchanges between Yale lawprof Jed Rubenfeld and Minnesota lawprof Michael Stokes Paulsen.”
It also contains three Tributes, an Article, an Essay, and the above-references Colloquium, which features five participating writers. Each and every author is male.
(NB: There are five student pieces as well, two notes and three comments, and it looks like one of the five student authors is actually female, woohoo.)