What's Realistic About the Depiction of Stalking in You? All rights reserved. All rights reserved. him. Hatters Friedman notes there's no single mental health condition associated with stalking. 2021 by Medical Wonders Ontario. He is also very manipulative and has a lack of empathy. the picture, so he became closer to Beck for himself (Fredrick, 2020). First off, he was interested in reading and writing, and he showed this off in various jobs and hobbies. Klestzick, Rebecca. Android & IOS users, download our mobile app for faster than ever Bollywood & Box Office updates! Joe was mentally ill. Hence, Joe clearly has issues with codependency, which inform the relationships he forms with women. On the outside, a cooling-down period may appear to be a peaceful process, but on the inside, the victim is constantly trying to figure out how to get over the narcissist. Please consider adding this before the end of the course. 2. To define stalking, it is viewed as an illogical or irrational preoccupation with another individual. While Joe Goldberg is an extreme type of psychopath, we can't guarantee milder versions won't enter your life. https://doi- It is significant to represent psychopaths, as it would teach us more about antisocial personality disorder, which anyone you know may be suffering from. In addition to my work in mental health, I am also a professional book reviewer. In the latest season, we watched Joe and Love move to the picturesque town of Madre Linda to raise their son, Henry. Grand Canyon University: PSY- Speaking of the swingers night, Love wouldnt know how to be lowkey if her life depended on it and it did. Pop Culture's Problematic Portrayal of Psychopathy. The Owl, bhsowl.org/5097/arts-entertainment/pop-cultures-problematic-portrayal-of-psychopathy/. He is a master in the skill of manipulating people using his innocent face. stressful situations due to how he grew up. This is an accurate example of how psychopaths gaslight others. He is a great example of how someone can be diagnosed using psychoanalysis. Then when Joe and Love invited Sherry and Cary over to have sex, Love went beserk when she noticed that Joe was simply fantasising about having sex with another woman. Psychoanalysis of "You"'s Joe Goldberg. Throughout You's first three seasons, Joe engages in a repeated pattern of behavior toward the characters he's become infatuated with: he meets a woman he finds attractive and fixates on her, he sifts through her social media profiles and other online activity, he starts to follow her in real life, he engineers "chance" meetings, and slowly insinuates himself into her life by presenting himself as the ideal man based on what he's learned about her. Ryan2 years ago what I needed to start mine Students also viewed PSY 255 Trait Theory Short Answer Worksheet Joe Goldbergs personality type is INFJ, which is the combination of the three functions (introverted Feeling, which is dominant in this type, moderately developed Sensing and judging), which provides him with an unusual perspective on life that he can use to compensate for his introverted intuition. Cognitive behavioral therapist Dr. Avigail Lev, director of Bay Area CBT Center and founder of CBT Online, gets more specific, diagnosing Joe with covert malignant narcissism. This is an accurate example of how psychopaths gaslight others. One day he got fed up with his mother being abused, he killed his father in So although some people with narcissistic traits can benefit from therapy, malignant narcissists "actually get worse with therapy. He is a serial killer, stalker and former bookstore manager who, upon meeting Guinevere Beck at his workplace in New York, starts to develop an extreme, toxic and delusional obsession. In You, Joe Goldberg exhibits "psychopathic traits and narcissistic traits," says Hatters Friedman. You is an American psychological thriller Netflix series which premiered in the year 2018. And if it comes to saving his a$$, he can kill his girlfriend too. While Joe Goldberg is an extreme type of psychopath, we can't guarantee milder versions won't enter your life. As stated in Kwon article, "At first, the 10. He is also paranoid and has a lot of anger. When he would be dealing with As for antisocial behavior, Joe does not have any friends, nor does he make any effort to befriend others, aside from children who he feels obligated to care for. She thrives on being innovative and adaptable, as well as looking for new ways to improve her company. People who are severely codependent tend to control their partner or the person they're codependent towards and define themselves primarily in relationship to their partner rather than having their own identity, Insider previously reported. Sign up for notifications from Insider! As a result, it is clear that Joe Goldberg is likely to suffer from antisocial and narcissistic personality disorder. Joe Goldberg, in his role as You, possesses many of these characteristics as a murderer. Joe Goldberg is a character in the novel and television series You who has been diagnosed as a narcissist by many readers and viewers. Despite Love thinking that she was killing to protect her marriage and family, she was just needlessly killing with no restraint. When she is in love, she enjoys stealing from and murdering her victims. : an American History (Eric Foner), The Methodology of the Social Sciences (Max Weber), PSY 255 Trait Theory Short Answer Worksheet, Introduction to Personality Media Analysis Worksheet, Persuasive Essay-Thesis Statement and Gathering Resources Worksheet. Even though society thinks this Love Quinn after any inconvenience #YouNetflix #YOUSEASON3 #YouS3 pic.twitter.com/aSmSGHqOg0. Joe Goldberg is a character in the novel You, who is a textbook psychopath. But on the other, he is the man of your dreams. he is a sociopath and is obsessed with Beck, he continually stalks her and gets rid of anyone who will distance her from Joe. (2020). Love and connection are primary factors that we often seek, and they are Joes primary motivation as well. So when we have empathy for someone, it hooks us in. Joe devalues his wife, Love, while also gaining his bosss affection in the shows latest season. While the target of stalking is certainly in danger from the intimacy-seeking stalker, Hatters Friedman adds that if "someone's seen as getting in the way [of the relationship between the stalker and their target], they may be at risk from the stalker [too].". J Am Acad Psychiatry Law. Predatory stalkers are planning to attack their victims and enjoy the sense of power the act of stalking gave them. ", They're masters of making "the right first impressions, creating this perception, weaving this little web in which they learn about you and stage their entrance into your life," says Neo. You is an American psychological thriller Netflix series which premiered in the year 2018. 2009 - 2023 MindBodyGreen LLC. Joe is very narcissistic and has a grandiose sense of self. Although he has done so much wrong, Goldberg still thinks he is a perfect individual, and lacks guilt to take accountability for his actions or even feel empathy towards the people who he has violated. As we see in season 2 and season 3, his troubled childhood and the fact that he was abandoned by his mother seemingly gave Joe severe codependency issues. If the whole show gave you a bad case of the creeps, Neo offered some additional advice. You've done a fantastic job of describing each of the defense mechanisms. Joe seemingly suffers from ASPD, with hints of psychopathy that cause him to commit heinous crimes but remain charming nonetheless. Both narcissistic and borderline individuals usually experience chronic instability in their personal Continue Reading 36 Sponsored by PureCare Knee Protector You is narrated by Joe Goldbergs ongoing monologues; these solo dialogues are what manipulate streamers into supporting him, and antagonising the characters who attempt sabotaging the stalkers devious plans. And as it so happens, we can learn a lot from Joe Goldberg. One thing that could improve this submission is a short summary of the show and characters at the very beginning. impulsive aggression and higher premeditated aggression (Azevedo, et al. Malignant narcissists exhibit the traits associated with narcissistic personality disorder, including grandiosity, entitlement and lack of empathy, but also have antisocial tendencies, including a lack of remorse and blaming others for their actions. He was also portrayed by Gianni Ciardiello, Aidan Wallace and Jack Fisher as a youth. "I always tell people: Pay attention when there's too much on the front end," Durvasula said. No one can predict the trajectory of a narcissistic cycle because it is a continuous pattern that does not end or end. he is a sociopath and is obsessed with Beck, he continually stalks her and gets rid of anyone who will distance her from Joe. of these categories. "People use the word 'psychopath' colloquially to describe a person whose behavior defies social norms and conventional understandings of right and wrong," Kelly Scott, a therapist at Tribeca Therapy in Manhattan, told Insider. Netflix came out with an unforgettable TV Series named "YOU." Penn Badgley played a "Although You's depiction of Joe as someone who can feel guilt and empathy toward his victims brings humanity to the character, it's also led some fans to romanticize him. Love (Victoria Pedretti) and Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley) are both serial killers. 2023 Dotdash Media, Inc. All rights reserved. In some ways, Goldberg embodies both conditions because he's constantly violent when he believes a person has wronged him, a common justification people with both illnesses make for their behavior. On top of that, he normalizes all his toxic characteristics, underlining that he does so in the name of love. These individuals often have a poor understanding of dating rituals as well as a sense of entitlement to a relationship. It can come out in parenting and using your child to meet your own needs in a way that is massively detrimental to your child's needs," like Goldberg's mother is seen doing in flashbacks during season 2. Deerfield Beach, FL: Despite continuously stalking, occasionally kidnapping and holding people captive, and several times even murdering others, Joe genuinely thinks he is a good guy. For example, when she murdered her nanny as a child, the Quinn family covered it up. problems daily, especially regarding his narcissistic, antisocial, or serial killer ways. definition has now broadened to include anyone who was "wounded" as a child, the so-called So far, two seasons have been released, and the highly anticipated third season is coming out this October. I utilize art therapy and bibliotherapy in my mental health work, and I work with individuals struggling with mental illness, as well as their loved ones. "It's very obvious from the beginning of [You] that [Joe] has narcissistic personality disorder," Lev observes. Dr. Nicky applies psychoanalysis in one . This is a Premium document. It is also possible that you will require professional assistance. have learned that social relationships are a source of anxiety, and their destructive interpersonal You can begin working on self-esteem and self-compassion as soon as you understand whats going on. but as the show progresses, the more dangerous he becomes, it's clear that he's a sociopath, because now he's moved into antisocial behaviors. "You". who was obsessed with women. antisocial disorder, being a narcissist, and co-dependency issues. Joe exhibits a number of personality traits that are typical of the disorder. What is that thing? But in the end, he didnt. household that has made him codependent as an adult. Burger, J. M. (2019). There are three types of serial killers. He always seems to mirror others, is dishonest, and completely selfish when it comes to his own child. In either case, youve realized that hes a Scorpio. For example, when Beck ex-lover, Benji, whom she did not want in her life anymore. The main couple in Season 3 has a very interesting connection. This typology is made up of five stalker types: Incompetent stalkers want to establish an intimate relationship with the individual they're stalking but recognize that their affections are not reciprocated. Fredrick, C. (2020, August 17). According to NCBI (National Center for Biotechnology Information), psychopathy is technically not a psychiatric diagnosis. Worrall, Daina. By: Ayesha Nayak. Anushka Sens Am I Next To Release Digitally This Womens Day, Actress Says Im Fortunate To Be A Part Of Such An Important Film, Farzi: Prime Video Curates A One-Of-A-Kind Show-Themed Perfume That Smells Of Freshly Minted Notes. Terms. He is a bookstore clerk, and that is where he gained most of his knowledge. There are many ways to tackle this question, including how it reflects our ideals of romance in a rapidly changing dating landscape. He loves to satisfy her and feels bad about himself when he fails to do so in his first attempt. Its worth paying close attention to what Joes sign indicates about his personality in either case. It appears you entered an invalid email. In fact, both Hatters Friedman and Lev point out that even though Joe may seem like he truly loves Beck, Love, or the other women he obsesses over, the show subtly demonstrates that, like a real-life malignant narcissist, he doesn't see these characters as human beings with strengths and weaknesses of their own. Narcissists use their victims as a way to create an illusion in order to fulfill their own fantasies. Joe Goldberg is one of those rare sociopaths who come across as very charming. Joe is not a control freak on the bed and loves his girl to come above him and dominate. Editor's note: This article contains spoilers for the television show "You.". He hurt his loved ones and others whom he suspected. Joe Goldberg from You or Dan Humphrey from Gossip Girl are two of the most recognizable characters you may have come across. Most of the mans crimes were committed out of pure impulse and he does not formulate entire plans to murder or kidnap people; instead, rage and panic are what drive him to do the things he does in the moment. Personality (10th ed.). Joe will do whatever in his means to help them out in Berlanti, G., & Gamble, S. (Directors). | She received her bachelor's in broadcasting and mass communication from State University of New York at Oswego, and lives in Buffalo, New York. He was a pleaser and wanted everything to be perfect. When we look at Joe's history, we see that he was brought up in a horrible, mistreated And what's more, with the ubiquity of dating apps today, anyone can manufacture a great first impression. People who engage in stalking behaviors can suffer from many issues, such as personality disorders like narcissistic personality disorder, delusional disorder, or attachment disorders. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. It is equally damaging to a persons psychological, spiritual, or social well-being if he or she is emotionally or spiritually abused. Cynthia Vinney, PhD is an expert in media psychology and a published scholar whose work has been published in peer-reviewed psychology journals. In You, Joe Goldberg exhibits "psychopathic traits and narcissistic traits," says Hatters Friedman. These flashbacks help viewers better understand the root cause of Goldberg's behavior and, according to Scott, these scenes led her to believe Goldberg acts how he does not because he lacks empathy and has antisocial personality disorder, but because his violent and turbulent childhood caused him to develop an attachment disorder. will not harm them, but he is thinking about something different. Some choose specific victims while others choose random victims based on a general sense of injustice and grievance with the world. Beforehand, let us go over some file]. They are charismatic and plan everything in advance to ensure that no one notices. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. https://img.mentalhealthmatters-cofe.org/1664432906274.5e1c915c49878c3a103bf3f3, https://www.mentalhealthmatters-cofe.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/logo.png, A Complex Character: Joe Goldberg From You. Joe is very narcissistic and has a grandiose sense of self. Joe Goldberg from You. She makes others feel guilty for themselves by doing so in subtle ways. It comes down to the empathy that Joe evokes, according to Neo. Joe is a pervert who doesnt have self control even a bit. Karen Cilli is a fact-checker for Verywell Mind. And its pretty iconic. You can stream all three seasons of Youon Netflix. Apart from my professional experience, I am a survivor of Schizoaffective Disorder, Quiet Borderline Personality Disorder, Fibromyalgia, multiple eating disorders, Generalized Anxiety Disorder, and Complex PTSD. For example, when the word psychopath or stalker comes to mind, one would highly likely picture a person with an unlikeable, strange personality who is scruffy, unkept, uneducated, and neither polite nor visually appealing. The goal of intimacy-seeking stalkers is to enter into a relationship with the person they're stalking, who they believe is meant to be with them. Spoiler alert! Get hand-picked resources and highlights from our Mighty community straight to your inbox. Even Penn Badgley himself had choice words for Joe's biggest fans. Moreover, when he stalks Beck's wealthy friend Peach, who believes he's not good enough for Beck in season 1, or the comedian Henderson, who may have predatory intentions toward underage Ellie in season 2, he becomes the resentful stalker who sees himself as defending the downtrodden against these entitled, underserving individuals. He is also very manipulative and has a lack of empathy. And we try to do that for other people, especially if we are very understanding of other people. To win over his ever-changing objects of desire, Joe also employs appalling means that are highly illegal. Even though Joe, unsettlingly played by Penn Badgley, is fictional, his patterns of behavior toward the latest object of his desire come across as frighteningly realistic. In Season 3 at least, one could argue that Joe killed for purpose (offing Ryan to give Marienne custody of her child and poisoning Love to free himself and Henry), while Love was impulsive and let jealousy and anger control her decisions. Azevedo, J., Vieira-Coelho, M., Castelo-Branco, M., Coelho, R., & Figueiredo-Braga, M. If Goldberg was not as good-looking, hilarious, sweet, or smart as he is portrayed in the show, with a different financial status, his character would not be well liked by fans, or even the side characters who trust him. Moreover, Joe's tragic backstory, which includes a mother who abandoned him after he shot and killed her abusive boyfriend and a foster father who locked him in a glass book cage for extended periods of time, establishes the roots of an attachment disorder that make it challenging for Joe to bond with or trust others. 2020). why we do things as we get older. Joe's fear of rejection and dissociation from his body (as manifested by compulsive masturbation, premature ejaculation, and impotence) are characteristic of borderline personality disorder. PloS One, 15 (3), e0229876. "Empathy is really about how we are compelled to understand why things are the way they are. Mental Health Specialist & Coach - Author - Bibliotherapist - Book Reviewer My name is Ashley Nestler, and I have my master's of social work with an emphasis in mental health, as well as certifications in mental health coaching, art therapy coaching, crystal healing, dialectical behavior therapy, and bibliotherapy. He fears that he wont be able to protect his son, Henry, from what he himself was subjected to as a child, and he struggles to form a connection with him. I use my personal experiences with my mental health and health to inform my work. Joe In the television series You, a number of personality disorders are observed, including the main characters. Retrieved on September 21, 2020 YOU [Video Joe also loves kids and wants to protect their childhood for the same reason. Contents 1 Biography 2 Personality 3 Victims "The show has this false layering of hope that [Joe] can get better or that [he] can have remorse or that [he] can change," Lev observes, "and [he can't]." Retrieved from netflix/watch/80212201?trackId=13752289. Furthermore, only some people with narcissistic personality disorder reach the level of malignant narcissism, the most severe form of the condition. Joe undertook therapy sessions, out of which a very significant method used by Sigmund Freud is exhibited in the show. This article contains major spoilers for the first three seasons of the TV show, You, now streaming on Netflix. Hatters Friedman and Lev particularly cited Joe's behavior toward his newborn son in the third season of the series as unrealistic. One reason it's difficult to pinpoint a single mental health condition for Goldberg is the simple fact "You" was created for television, according to Pamela Rutledge, a social scientist who researches the intersection of media, human behavior, and neuroscience. Oops! And in many cases in reality, people do choose the dark road. and respect from his mother, which did not work at the end. Joe's development of obsessions with different women often leads to violence due to his inability to create and maintain positive relationships, and he often resorts to violence when he feels as though he is being abandoned. Guinevere Beck was a central character in television series, You, serving as the titular love interest in season 1 as well as a posthumous character in season 2. Hence, Joe seems to have a form of ASPD (sociopathy), as opposed to him being a complete psychopath. But when Love had sex with Theo, she didnt even mention it to Joe. When he acts on these feelings to women, stalking can gain that love back (Burger, 2019). 38/40. Whitfield, C. L. (1991). He was a sociopath,had co- dependency issues and as slightly hinted by dr. Nick he can have 2 personalities. Cynthia Vinney, PhD is an expert in media psychology and a published scholar whose work has been published in peer-reviewed psychology journals. However, at different times Joe also demonstrates behavior consistent with the rejected stalker, the resentful stalker, and the predatory stalker (although he's never the incompetent stalker). Powered by WordPress.com VIP. After finding out that he is having a son, rather than a daughter like he had hoped, Joe becomes distraught. Joe seems like a hopeless romantic References "Joe [Goldberg] would be a good example of misdiagnosis," Scott said. Joe Goldberg When it comes to the most intelligent characters on You, Joe Goldberg would have to be named number one. But at least Joe was methodical and careful in his approach to murdering people. Then when she shoved the Conrads in her glass box and Joe tried to think of non-violent ways to deal with the couple, Love handed them a gun and forced them to shoot each other. Overall, the writers and directors of You have done a great job with depicting a psychopath. And no matter what he's doing to win the heart of his latest obsession, including theft and murder, he sees all of his behavior as justified because it is done to help her and their relationship. Sorry???? According to Scott, a season 2 scene when Goldberg looks distraught after he learns his landlord Delilah has been killed proves that Goldberg does indeed have empathy and therefore doesn't have antisocial personality disorder. 27-29)." Looking deeper into Antisocial Personality Disorder, Strangership and Privilege in Netflix's You.. personality disorder. In essence, they Of course, he does seem to have a fair amount of charisma, which means he also imbibes psychopathic traits. Burger stated that "According to Karen Horney, children growing up in anxiety- She received her bachelor's in broadcasting and mass communication from SUNY Oswego, and lives in Buffalo, New York. some symptoms of being antisocial. Mind in the Media: What's So Appealing About Oddball Wednesday Addams? Also, he has a sign of being an individual who can be very Goldberg shows signs of antisocial personality disorder. At the same time, Scott said it's important to note that not all people with antisocial personality disorder or an attachment disorder will act violently. Tell us you love Punkee without telling us you love Punkee. He wants to change, he wants to do things better, and we root for a person who wants to change and transform. Yet, the series doesn't acknowledge this reality. Joe devalues his ex-girlfriends in order to manipulate the narrative. On December 26, Netflix released the highly-anticipated second season of its original thriller series "You," which centers around narrator Joe Goldberg, a young man who has a pattern of becoming obsessed with certain women, stalking them, winning them over, and killing anyone around them he believes has wronged his lover. While we've known Joe Goldberg to be the obsessive stalker with murderous tendencies for three seasons of You, Love Quinn proved that she was the true psycho of the series in Season 3. He loves to read their mind and even though he is wrong most of the times, Joe believes he knows women best. You can reach out to the National Domestic Violence Hotline by calling victimconnect.org or the hotline.org. ", Joe's behavior could even seem romantic "to those of us who have been brought up on Disney and rom-coms practically IV-dripped into our consciousness. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. boundaries and relationality. The first and second seasons' plots revolve around the seemingly normal life of . This has helped him cope with dealing with specific He also tends to hold women hostage when he is interested in them, because he doesn't know how to form healthy relationships. She is also highly independent and takes risks, which is something she enjoys doing. Goldberg "seems to be an amalgam of personality traits at abnormal levels that are constructed to make a good story and create a character that elicits a certain amount of empathy" in viewers, despite the fact he murders people, Rutledge told Insider. him throughout the season. Since he is a fictional character, the more we find out about him in subsequent seasons, the more accurate a diagnosis of his mental state can be made. According to Mental Health America, symptoms of codependency include a need to control others and an unhealthy dependence on relationships. Highest Grossing Hindi Dubbed South Films. What Does It Really Mean To Be An Extrovert. If you are an Aries, you may find Joe to be overly emotional. That was, of course, until Love caught wind of Joes attention shifting away from her and onto neighbour, Natalie Engler. Natalie wasnt a threat to her family because Joe decided to not pursue the relationship, yet Love still murdered her. He falls in love with those women who he thinks need his help. Not as a real person but i rooted for him because of the way he treated beck and how he showered her with "love and Care", I believed he could turn out to be good. Because . Love, however, didnt give a single shit about that. Joe is adopted and cared for by a man named Mr. Mooney, but Joe is not treated well; he is locked in a glass cabinet filled with books, It is only natural for him to feel whatever he wants to feel and to instantly transform into someone else. Love does not care about consequences or the messes she makes. We all like to think we're great judges of character. Why Does Everyone like Joe Goldberg?" Unlike Joe and Love, both serial killers are typically narcissistic, whereas Joe is a textbook example ofYandere, whereas Love is a typical, garden-variety killer. In contrast to Joe, a Cancer would be someone who would bring out the best in you. NOW WATCH: Los Angeles loves this innovative taco omakase, pattern of becoming obsessed with certain women, term "psychopath" doesn't hold much meaning, medically speaking, people with antisocial personality disorder, more inclined to break the law than those with narcissistic personality disorder, narcissists fly under the radar because they use their charm, Penn Badgley admits it's 'not entirely fair' to blame 'You' fans for thirsting over Joe, despite slamming them in the past, 6 things you probably didn't know about the making of season 2 of Netflix's 'You', Joe from 'You' is probably a love addict, and an expert says it's more common than you might think. raised him, and even taught him an education. they have gone through, which connects them unconsciously. Ever.". COMPARISON OF THEORISTS: Joe Goldberg It also makes us a lot wiser in trusting our own gut and our own wisdom," she says.