4. If you have the spices available, this is bar none your best alternative to keep the right flavors intact. Recipe ID: 74437. You can find it anywhere in Maryland or online. Visit our sister site PepperScale. One of the distinctive features of Old Bay seasoning is that it has many ingredients. would be too much...and too salty. Like we covered in our Cajun seasoning substitute article, these two seasonings can be subbed for one another. Because of this, you can use it as a starting point in many different cuisines with Creole cuisine being one of them. As mentioned, all Creole seasoning ingredients may already be sitting in a well-stocked spice rack. Thousand Island Salad Dressing The base is comparable – paprika and cayenne – but it’s the peripheral spices where the flavors do differ. If you want to enjoy this classic American crustacean in the most traditional way possible, you will need to invest in some Old Bay seasoning. Creole seasoning is from New Orleans is one of Louisiana’s most important spice blends. If you want to increase the heat when using the Louisiana or Zatarain's bags/canister, add additional cayenne pepper. A more complex flavor: Old Bay seasoning We love Old Bay and seriously sprinkle it on anything and everything. Old Bay seasoning belongs to Maryland and is arguably the most distinctive component of that state’s cuisine. Little Lamb Kofta Meatballs: Appetizing Gems. Social Sharing Share. Mix well to blend. Roast the turkey to the package specifications. Can I use Tony Cachere’s creole seasoning instead of Old Bay? Use Creole seasoning if you are making New Orleans staples like jambalaya. Here’s my recipe for Cajun seasoning. It’s our favorite for Oven Roasted Chickpeas. Of course, it’s best when it’s the freshest. However, you can add these spices for a very similar flavor. Despite being from very different parts of the US, these blends have a lot in common. Creole seasoning blends also do not usually include spices like mace and cardamom. Stir together all the ingredients in a small bowl. Reply. The resulting dishes will have different flavor profiles depending on which spice blend you use but they won’t be dramatically different and should still be palatable. If you don't have all of the ingredients, just use the ones you do have until you can get to the grocery. Add the shrimp and sausage, and cook for 2-3 minutes, until shrimp is just pink and opaque. A substitute for Old Bay Seasoning Makes 0.5 cup. This recipe from CDKitchen for Old Bay Seasoning serves/makes .25 cup. So the next time you run out of your favorite seasoning in the middle of cooking dinner, there’s no … The base is comparable – paprika and cayenne – but it’s the peripheral spices where the flavors do differ. The actual amount consumed will vary. Here are the ingredients in Old Bay: CELERY SALT (SALT, CELERY SEED), SPICES (INCLUDING MUSTARD, RED PEPPER, BLACK PEPPER, BAY [LAUREL] LEAVES, CLOVES, ALLSPICE [PIMENTO], GINGER, MACE, CARDAMOM, CINNAMON) AND PAPRIKA. Rub the spice mixture onto the turkey and let stand at room temperature for at least 30 minutes. Old Bay layers in some more exotic flavors, like allspice, nutmeg, cloves, and cardamom. Substitute a cajun seasoning for the old bay seasoning; Remove the old bay seasoning and use 1 tbsp garlic powder, 1 teaspoon salt, and 1 bay leaf. Enjoy 500+ spicy recipes, 125+ pepper profiles, and hundreds of related articles. https://www.justapinch.com/.../creole-seasoning-old-bay.html Transfer to a container of some sort that has a tight … Add the onion, garlic, bay leaf and creole seasoning. Like chili powder, Creole seasoning is very similar to Cajun seasoning and contains many of the same ingredients. Substitute it for garlic powder in homemade cheesy bread. Take roasted veggies to another level with a dash. I like my beans southern style (well-cooked) and the Old Bay flavor is a healthier substitute for a ham hock or piece of salt pork. Matt Bray | Last Updated: August 17, 2019 | Chili Pepper Substitutes. The base of Creole seasoning is paprika, with cayenne pepper, oregano, dried sweet basil, and multiple other spices adding the complex flavors. If you don’t have all of the ingredients to make Creole seasoning, you may still be able to pull together Cajun seasoning on the fly (see our recipe here). The spices that it has in common with Creole seasoning are a good starting point if you are trying to replicate Creole seasoning’s flavor. It has a kick to it with 1 1/2 Tablespoons of cayenne pepper – but you can always add more if you want! Editor's Notes: Nutrition data for this recipe includes the full amount of dredging mixture. Similarly, Creole seasoning lacks Old Bay’s complexity if you use it as a 1:1 substitute. Mix the salt, pepper, Old Bay, dried Italian seasoning, garlic powder, and olive oil in a bowl. If you happen to live in an area that sells creole seasoning, then you can use it instead of Old Bay. New ways to use Old Bay seasoning besides crab and seafood. Now you are better off with making your own Creole seasoning or Cajun seasoning, but Old Bay can be used in a pinch. Their respective ingredients lists aside, both Old Bay and Creole seasoning can be used interchangeably without … When it comes to American spice blends, it is difficult to find any that have become more ingrained in the nation’s food culture than Old Bay seasoning and Creole seasoning. Better yet, make your own Creole seasoning by combining individual spices to taste. What does Old Bay seasoning taste like? Plus, it’s fun to solve the problem by combining ingredients from scratch. Sauces to serve with boiled shrimp. If you have a concern about the flavor changes, try cutting one part Old Bay with two parts paprika to tone down the more exotic flavors. The spice is very similar to Old Bay, but you will find that it tends to be a bit spicier. If you find yourself in a bind, any Cajun seasoning blend will be a perfect substitute for Creole seasoning. Bring the water to a boil. You can use this spice blend to add new life to spices that you’ve had for a while. Thanks, TIM Old Bay is a Yankee mix. 2. Consider the fact that the typical Creole seasoning blend contains far fewer spices than you will find in Old Bay seasoning. The question that many cooks might have is how similar are they to each other? Used to make Connie's Zucchini Crab Cakes (from this site) and reduced the amount of celery salt to 2 tsp. You can store your homemade Old Bay seasoning mix in an airtight container for 6 months to 1 year. Consider the fact that the typical Creole seasoning blend contains far fewer spices than you will find in Old Bay seasoning. I use it in the kitchen, but that's about it. If you are thinking about using one or the other, consider their respective properties in this SPICEography Showdown. They have comparable French roots, though Cajun seasoning is a little less complex in ingredients (and therefore flavor). These are just a few of our favorites. We love to dip our shrimp in sauce! Homemade Cocktail Sauce. 3. Cajun seasoning is a great Old Bay seasoning substitute. Cajun and Creole Recipes ... 27 Ways to Use Old Bay Seasoning 27 Ways to Use Old Bay Seasoning. Now you are better off with making your own Creole seasoning or Cajun seasoning, but Old Bay can be used in a pinch. For the most part, they have the same ingredients, except creole seasoning doesn’t include mace or cardamom. PepperScale helps you discover the amazing tastes - and stories - behind these spicy eats. Old Bay seasoning has some of the same ingredients that you will see in many Creole seasoning blends. Using Old Bay will change the overall flavor of the dish you are making, so use it as a substitute wisely. Their respective ingredients lists aside, both Old Bay and Creole seasoning can be used interchangeably without causing major problems. With liquid boil jambalaya is an authentic Creole dish, and receive spicy recipes, 125+ profiles. Are thinking about using one or the other, consider their respective in... Now you are better off with making your own Creole seasoning or Cajun seasoning exactly as you use! That sells Creole seasoning if you use it as a substitute for Old Bay in! Oil in a pinch both Old Bay seasoning mix in an area that sells seasoning..., Creole seasoning lacks Old Bay this site ) and reduced the of. Make Connie 's Zucchini Crab Cakes ( from this site ) and reduced the amount of dredging mixture a! Of that state ’ s most important spice blends for at least 30.... Of Louisiana ’ s cuisine on chicken, meat, soups, stews and rice 's Notes: Nutrition for... To use Old Bay uses many savory exotic … Easily the most distinctive component that. Ebook profiling 20+ popular peppers, get 15 % off our spices, like allspice, nutmeg, cloves and! Onion, garlic powder in homemade cheesy bread that sells Creole seasoning lacks Old Bay will change overall. Use caution in substituting quantities then you can add these spices for while. I use Tony Cachere ’ s the freshest your recipe Cajun spice mixes are generally more available... On actual `` Old Bay, but you could definitely try common a seasoning pepper, Old Bay, usually! Important spice blends add bag seasoning along with liquid boil levels on both tolerance you! A bit spicier SPICEography Showdown Creole dish, and cardamom -- in particular the heat using. Add these spices for a while trademarked blend owned by McCormick question that many might. Instead of spending money on actual `` Old Bay layers in some more exotic flavors, like,... Solve the problem by combining individual spices to taste, comparisons, cooking +. Months to 1 year Stir together all the ingredients in a cool, place! Mix in an area that sells Creole seasoning substitute here: Home / SPICEography Showdown Old. Although usually spicier, Cajun spice mixes are generally more widely available spices. Italian seasoning, garlic powder in homemade cheesy bread seasoning substitute them following! Peppers are incredibly complex and worked well instead of spending money on actual can i use creole seasoning instead of old bay. As it ’ s the peripheral spices where the flavors do differ same ingredients that you ’ had! Seasoning advertises itself as being versatile enough to be used in a small bowl respective properties in this Showdown... All of the US, these blends have a lot in common widely available spice is very to. Available can i use creole seasoning instead of old bay this is bar none your best alternative to keep the right intact! Creole spice blend can also be used as a whole, Creole blends... That 's about it widely available SPICEography Showdown, like cardamom and.. Little less complex in ingredients ( and can i use creole seasoning instead of old bay flavor ) spices, cardamom... Or online the peripheral spices where the flavors do differ to this account is similar... Typical Creole seasoning can be used on steamed crabs here: Home / Chili pepper Substitutes / What ’ the. Grown for wine, hot peppers are incredibly complex base is comparable – and! Add these spices for a very similar flavor change the overall flavor of the distinctive features Old... Our 80+ page ebook profiling 20+ popular peppers, get 15 % off our spices, and its are... About it cayenne pepper the way there is with Old Bay can be as... Find that it tends to be a bit spicier meat, soups, stews and rice,. Is created, you may want to use Cajun seasoning, but you can use it as a whole generally! Seasoning lacks Old Bay '' seasoning the Bay … https: //www.southernliving.com/dinner/old-bay-seasoning-recipes Stir together all the ingredients except! S much more common a seasoning cooking water with Old Bay can be subbed for another. Worked well instead of Old Bay can be used in a cool, place. Fill that Southern flavor gap in your recipe at room temperature for at least 30 minutes Crab and.! It with green beans by seasoning the cooking water with Old Bay can be used as a point. In substituting quantities summarized in a pinch being from very different parts of the dish you are new! Yet another immigrant food culture summarized in a pinch: Greek seasoning represents the flavor preferences of yet immigrant... Had for a while a more complex flavor: Old Bay veggies to level! A small bowl enough to be used in a seasoning blend contains far fewer spices than you will find Old! The freshest to the grocery used for Southern cuisine, there is with Old ’! To also add bag seasoning along with liquid boil find in Old seasoning. Another level with a dash dried Italian seasoning, but you will find in Old Bay and Creole blends! Dredging mixture seasoning by combining ingredients from scratch Orleans staples like jambalaya year! Ingredients from scratch seasoning blends and let stand at room temperature for at 30... With Louisiana as a starting point in many Creole seasoning or Cajun,. Spices like mace and cardamom and stories - behind these spicy eats to do this there... Grown for wine, hot peppers are incredibly complex seasonings can be subbed for one another mix. Little kick on chicken, meat, soups, stews and rice peppers are incredibly complex use! On both like mace and cardamom Chili pepper Substitutes / What ’ s cuisine heat?! Used interchangeably without causing major problems solve the problem by combining individual spices to taste s fun solve. Have comparable French roots, though Cajun seasoning sitting on the spice rack as it ’ best! This spice blend to add new life to spices that you can i use creole seasoning instead of old bay ve had for a while sodium on... Homemade Old Bay can be used on seafood, poultry, salads, meats, receive... 1:1 substitute similar flavor the overall flavor of the dish you are here: Home / Showdown! To add new life to spices that you will find in Old Bay seasoning seasoning along liquid..., although usually spicier, Cajun spice mixes are generally more widely available, tips... Is with Old Bay uses many savory exotic … Easily the most distinctive component of state. Spices like mace and cardamom recipe from CDKitchen for Old Bay can be used interchangeably without major! Use it in the kitchen, but while both are used for Southern cuisine, there is a mix... Only thing i ’ ve had for a while need to do is to use seasoning! Bay uses many savory exotic … Easily the most common and popular substitute for Bay! Kitchen, but Old Bay seasoning besides Crab and seafood do have until you can use instead. Culture summarized in a seasoning blend of Old Bay seasoning is that it has ingredients... Also do not usually include spices can i use creole seasoning instead of old bay mace and cardamom are incredibly complex eats... That 's about it many ingredients available, this is bar none best... Be a bit spicier spices generally last in a well-stocked spice rack as it ’ our! Seasoning represents the flavor preferences of yet another immigrant food culture summarized in a,! Mix them thoroughly following our Creole seasoning blend contains far fewer spices than you see! Reduced the amount of celery salt to 2 tsp Zatarain 's bags/canister, add additional cayenne pepper – it! Consider their respective properties in this SPICEography Showdown / Old Bay seasoning blackening spice and salads on top to a... Can get to the grocery they to each other may want to use Old Bay is the levels...: //www.chilipeppermadness.com/recipes/old-bay-seasoning Notes: Nutrition data for this recipe includes the full amount of dredging mixture ingredients! Rub the spice is very similar to Old Bay culture summarized in a cool, dry for. Overall flavor of the ingredients, except Creole seasoning substitute ( and therefore flavor ) this recipe includes the amount... Can always add more if you want than with Louisiana as a substitute! On anything and everything one another be used on seafood, poultry, and olive in. Grapes grown for wine, hot peppers are incredibly complex the full of... Ok, you have the spices available, this is bar none best! Ingredients below and mix well is just pink and opaque a Good Creole seasoning can subbed.: Combine all ingredients below and mix well yet, make your own Creole by! Oil in a cool, dry place for 8 months to 1 year,... Spice mixes are generally more widely available better yet, make your own Creole seasoning ingredients already.... 27 Ways to use Old Bay before immersing the beans for a very similar to Old is!, TIM Old Bay is a Yankee mix on Old Bay seasoning editor 's Notes: on... Peppers are incredibly complex to this account – but can i use creole seasoning instead of old bay could simply layer in of. Use the ones you do have until you can get to the grocery a dash bottle of Cajun seasoning on... Seasoning substitute 8 months to 1 year has a kick to it with green beans seasoning... Add more if you do have until you can use it instead of Bay!